jump to navigation

Protest over the arrest of Chhatradhar Mahato September 29, 2009

Posted by juktibadi in Uncategorized.
add a comment

Chhatradhar Mahato, the leader and spokesperson of the PCPA (People’s Committee against Police Atrocities)* was arrested along with eight others, by policemen impersonating as journalists on Saturday, 26 September, 2009 from Kantapahari charged with sedition and also charges under the stringent UAPA – Unlawful Activities Prevention Act.

We know from The Times of India, dated 28.09.09:–

“Koushik Sinha and Prasanta Roy, counsels for the accused claimed that police had tortured Chhatradhar and eight others so badly that they were unable to walk properly. The prosecution however argued that they were injured when they “fell down while trying to escape.” Chhatradhar was charged under UAPA sections 16/B, 17, 18, 20, 38, 39 and 40, where he is accused of raising funds for a terror organization, attempting to murder security force members and conspiring against the state to create terror. He also faces charges under IPC sections 120B, 121, 121A and 307 – sedition, waging war against the state and attempt to murder.”

“Policemen impersonating as journalists to arrest Mahato came in for criticism from intellectuals and journalists on Sunday. Incensed with the impersonation, Press Club, Kolkata shot off letters to Union home minister P. Chidambaram, chief minister Buddhadeb Bhattacharya, chief secretary Ashok Mohan Chakrabarti and home secretary Ardhendu Sen condemning the way Chhatradhar was arrested”.

* * *

Humanists’ Association & Science and Rationalists Association of India have strongly condemned the arrest and demanded immediate, unconditional release of Chhatradhar in a press release. The news was published in ‘Sambad’, ‘Akdin’ and some other papers.

We know that policemen have to be in uniform and not only disclose their own identity while arresting someone, but also inform the reason for arrest. According to the Indian constitution, Mahato had the right to know why he was being arrested. The whole methodology was illegal and unethical.


* People’s Committee against Police Atrocities was formed on 7 November 2008, with 10 members from each of 98 villages in the tribal-inhabited Jangalmahal spread among the poorest and most neglected districts of West Bengal (Bankura-Purulia-Midnapur).

But why this PCPA — why was it necessary to unite?

On 2 November, 2008, a landmine exploded near the convoy of the W.Bengal chief minister in Jangalmahal. The next few days saw unheard of atrocities in the villages of Bankura and Purulia. Women were manhandled, old village teachers were shamed, stripped in front of students …

On 6 November, under the leadership of police superintendent of Lalgarh, policemen under the pretext of looking for the culprits (Maoists) intensified their search and misbehavior. The thin, dark-skinned, undernourished villagers were treated as something worse than animals. It is on this day that a tribal woman Chitamoni Murmu lost both her eyeballs with the sharp stroke of the butt of a policeman’s gun. The long neglect and poverty were bearable, but active misbehavior, torture and molestation were not to be borne by this peaceful and self-reliant people. They decided to protest. Yes, protest against ‘Police Atrocities’.

Mahato’s role as an able and upright leader among the poorest ethnic group in Bengal became clear soon. He spoke in all his public meetings about justice and led his men and women who gathered in thousands to peaceful demonstration. It was difficult to find anything unreasonable in all his speeches or demands. As Mahashweta Debi pointed out, he was the able leader of the most tenacious people’s movement of the era.

Now the cowardly arrest of Chhatradhar by disguised policemen and his torture, without any clear proof of his charges only make such bodies like PCPA more justifiable. It only makes it legitimate to unite against police atrocities – everywhere – all the more. Hundreds of young men and bread-earners of poor tribal village families were maimed and arrested without any proof of their involvement; women who went in peaceful processions demanding their release were mercilessly beaten up and ended in hospitals – in the last 3 months.

We have to agree with PCPA secretary Shibu Soren when he says – “If Maoists trigger a mine blast, how can he(Chhatradhar Mahato) be blamed for it? If CPM backed goons ransack and set fire to opposition party leaders’ houses, will Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee & Biman Bose be arrested?”

We demand… 11.09.09 September 11, 2009

Posted by juktibadi in Featured Article of the Month.
add a comment
DEMAND on 11 September

On this day 16 years ago in Kolkata was born HUMANISTS’ ASSOCIATION, preaching ‘Humanism’ as religion and working for protection of human rights.

Today on 11 September 2009, the newspaper brimmed with sickening news like —

–5 girls die in stampede inside school building
–a pharmacy student fights for life in hospital after being ragged by seniors
–30 tribal women severely injured by lathicharge carried on by joint (police & military) forces

There are many more inside. One has to close the paper in disgust and disbelief. Is this the world we are living in? How long do we intend to carry on like this?


While the first two of the above can be termed as accident and aberration, what about the third? The planned abuse of human rights going on in the most underdeveloped (or undevelped?) area of West Bengal, known as ‘Jangalmahal’ is going beyond all norms of civilised society. This is done by the ruling party. Why? Is this some sort of war? Against our own people?

Or are they not ‘our own’? They are a little different.They shame us by their poverty, their decades-long neglect and most importantly– their tenacity, their ability to fight for justice at last! Is that the reason why our leaders and decision-makers cannot bear the sight of them?

Then they need not stop till they finish them all. Exterminate them like some infectitious and obnoxious sore on our society. They can do it fast and finish them all. That, would be a little more humane.

It is more than 3 months now since the war in the forests of Bengal started. Let us not keep quiet any longer, let us be very clear in our views, let us unitedly condemn the very presence of ‘Jouthabahini’ or joint forces in our own state under any pretext.

We demand withdrawal of joint forces with immediate effect.

Humanists’ Association